Website Search
ID 15230

Holmes' conclusions at Buck vs. Bell, Paul Lombardo

Description:
Interviewee: Paul Lombardo. In the Supreme Court decision, Justice Holmes compared sterilization for feeblemindedness to a vaccination for smallpox. (DNAi Location: Chronicle > Trial of Carrie Buck > Epilogue > A false analogy)
Transcript:
Justice Holmes' opinion in the Buck case concluded that there was little difference between a vaccination for smallpox and an operation to interrupt someone's reproductive potential. In fact this was a false analogy: the vaccination case upon which his notion rested, only fined a man five dollars who refused to be vaccinated.
Keywords:
oliver wendell holmes,carrie buck,false analogy,supreme court decision,justice holmes,dnai,interviewee,lombardo,five dollars,sterilization,vaccination,smallpox,epilogue,conclusions,notion
Downloads:
Creative Commons License This work by Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License.

Related content:

15227. Holmes' statements at Buck vs. Bell, Paul Lombardo
Paul Lombardo talks about Oliver Wendell Holmes' support for eugenic sterilization was contrary to his record as a defender of civil liberties.
15221. Oliver Wendell Holmes
Paul Lombardo talks about justice Oliver Wendell Holmes' Supreme Court decisions contained a number of memorable phrases, and Buck vs. Bell provided him an opportunity to create another.
15220. The Buck vs. Bell decision, Paul Lombardo
Paul Lombardo talks about the case conluded that Carrie, Emma, and Vivian represented three generations of imbeciles, which justified Carrie's sterilization.
15759. Oliver Wendell Holmes
The Buck vs. Bell case then went to the U.S. Supreme Court, where Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. gave the majority opinion.
12191. "The Progress of Eugenical Sterilization," by Paul Popenoe, Journal of Heredity (vol. 25:1), including journal cover and contents page (6)
"The Progress of Eugenical Sterilization," by Paul Popenoe, Journal of Heredity (vol. 25:1), including journal cover and contents page (6)
15236. Carrie Buck's lawyer working against her interests, Paul Lombardo
Paul Lombardo talks about Carrie's lawyer, Irving Whitehead, colluded with lawyers representing the Virginia Colony to help insure that the case went to the Supreme Court.
15237. Low point in medical jurisprudence, Paul Lombardo
Paul Lombardo talks about low point in medical jurisprudence.
15225. The historical significance of Buck vs. Bell, Paul Lombardo
Paul Lombardo talks about the historical significance of Buck vs. Bell.
12190. "The Progress of Eugenical Sterilization," by Paul Popenoe, Journal of Heredity (vol. 25:1), including journal cover and contents page (5)
"The Progress of Eugenical Sterilization," by Paul Popenoe, Journal of Heredity (vol. 25:1), including journal cover and contents page (5)
15233. Lies at Buck vs. Bell, Paul Lombardo
Paul Lombardo talks about although Carrie was not feebleminded or morally degenerate, this was the way she was portrayed by the lawyers.
Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory
CSHL HomeAbout CSHLResearchEducationNews & FeaturesCampus & Public EventsCareersGiving