Website Search
ID 15017

Reaction to outrage over recombinant DNA, Paul Berg

Interviewee: Paul Berg. Paul Berg recollects his reaction to his colleague Bob Pollack's opposition to experimentation with recombinant DNA. (DNAi Location: Manipulation > Revolution > Players > Paul Berg > Reaction to outrage)
My first reaction was that this was absurd, I didn't see any risk to it, and as we began to discuss the thing over a period of time one could imagine ways to ameliorate that risk, was to use molecules that couldn't be transferred outside the cell, he would argue that if you may use your bacteria and they get into your gut they can transfer what you put into them into other organisms that could spread and so on. And I thought that was highly unlikely, but nevertheless after some consideration and consultation with various people, Joshua Lederberg was one, some of, other colleagues that I knew who were familiar with what we were doing, I think I came to the conclusion that I could not say with one hundred percent assurance that this experiment would pose zero risk.
joshua lederberg,paul berg video,recombinant dna,dnai,interviewee,recombination,pollack,time one,bacteria,organisms,molecules,manipulation,colleague,period of time,colleagues,opposition,consultation,conclusion,risk
Creative Commons License This work by Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License.

Related content:

15018. Outrage over recombinant DNA, Paul Berg
Paul Berg's student, Janet Mertz, planned an experiment that would recombine DNA from a monkey virus with DNA from a bacterium that lives in the human gut. Berg describes colleague Bob Pollack's outrage at this.
15024. The origin and utility of recombinant DNA, Paul Berg
Paul Berg discusses the usefulness of recombinant DNA to isolate and study genes.
15022. How the first recombinant DNA was created, Paul Berg
Paul Berg speaks about his student Janet Mertz's experiment to make the first recombinant DNA molecule.
15025. On the phenomenon of restriction, Paul Berg
Paul Berg speaks about Herbert Boyer's research into the process by which an organism, such as a bacterium, can recognize and destroy foreign DNA.
15020. Possible dangers of recombinant DNA, Paul Berg
Paul Berg talks about possible dangers of recombinant DNA.
15023. The experiment that galvanized the scientific community, Paul Berg
Paul Berg talks about why experiments with recombinant DNA set off a firestorm of controversy, including a moratorium on further experimentation with rDNA.
15019. Cohesive (sticky) ends and their significance in genetic engineering, Paul Berg
Paul Berg talks about cohesive (sticky) ends and their significance in genetic engineering.
15021. The moratorium letter regarding risky experiments, Paul Berg
In 1974, scientists in the field of recombinant DNA drafted a letter calling upon "scientists throughout the world" to suspend certain types of studies until hazards could be assessed. Paul Berg talks about the "Moratorium Letter."
15158. Bridging evolutionary barriers, Robert Pollack
Renowned biologist and philosopher Robert Pollack reflects on his concern over the potential danger of Janet Mertz's experiment inserting a cancer-causing gene from a monkey virus into a bacterium that lives in humans.
15256. Producing rat insulin using recombinant DNA, Walter Gilbert
Walter Gilbert talks about his group's early success with isolating the rat insulin gene and making recombinant rat insulin.
Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory
CSHL HomeAbout CSHLResearchEducationPublic EventsNewsstandPartner With UsGiving